– We’ve been in that cave forever

– Three days is not forever

– It is with this family

The Croods, DreamWorks animated feature, 2013

UNLIKE the bumbling Stone Age family of The Croods, most of us have spent a lot more than three days in our caves over the past 18 months.

The roller-coaster of lockdowns and reopenings and the ever-changing restrictions are hard for everybody, although the burden isn’t always distributed equally.

Lockdowns are particularly tough on those who’ve lost employment or seen a hard-won business go to the wall, for those who live alone or in unsafe domestic environments, and for parents trying to do their jobs remotely while also schooling their children.

More broadly, the pandemic has exposed, and in some cases exacerbated, long-standing socio-economic inequities.

Globally, COVID-19 is so far responsible for more than 4 million deaths and an unknown ongoing health burden in over 200 million survivors. It’s taken a huge toll on frontline health workers, including those caring for the more than 700 patients with COVID-19 currently in Australian hospitals.

But let’s not forget the real victims here: the people who are – and I know you’re going to find it hard to believe this could happen in contemporary Australia – being coerced against their will into placing a piece of fabric over their mouth when in public places.

An abuse of human rights on this scale should be taken to the United Nations.

Except, no, they’re probably part of the conspiracy, along with Big Pharma, and the government, and all the doctors who are getting paid off to lie about vaccines.

So, what’s a freedom fighter to do?

Taking to the streets is a popular option, as recent protests against masks, lockdowns, vaccination and other public health measures in Australia and elsewhere have demonstrated.

“I fully support your right to hide in your house and wear a face diaper until you can take an untested vax developed by corporations that cant [sic] be sued for an adverse reaction as long as you fully support my right not to do those things,” read one sign at a Sydney protest earlier this year.

The focus on individual freedom has been a striking feature of protests and other activism against COVID-19 restrictions.

Perhaps I’ve missed it, but nowhere have I seen freedom protesters supporting those who’ve been hardest hit by the lockdowns, calling for more income support for those who’ve lost their jobs, for example, or for better health services in disadvantaged communities.

Instead, the small but noisy minority refusing to comply with public health measures inflicts their sense of personal entitlement on just about every organisation that has to interact with the public.

One GP told me last week about a patient who refused to wear a mask while waiting for an appointment.

Furious at then being asked to wait outside, rather than in the waiting room, the patient went on to make a complaint of discrimination. The practice’s insurer said they’d been inundated by similar cases.

Because what the health system needs right now is to be tied up responding to people who see a face mask as the ultimate attack on their freedoms.

Have a look at what’s happening in Afghanistan, people.

Seventeenth-century English philosopher Thomas Hobbes is generally credited with developing the idea of the “social contract”, a concept he, and other Enlightenment philosophers, believed could protect us against the self-interest that motivated all humans (or, as he would have put it, all men).

A man should be willing, when others were too, “to lay down [his] right to all things; and be contented with so much liberty against other men as he would allow other men against himself”, he argued in his 1651 work, Leviathan.

When every man had the right to do anything he liked, all men would be “in the condition of war”, Hobbes wrote.

The cult of individualism bedevils our age, undermining the social contract and enabling those who seek to put even their most trivial desires ahead of larger common goods.

A fish rots from the head, as the old saying has it. The focus in our political culture on personal ambition ahead of public service, on point scoring ahead of substance, certainly sets a bad example.

Sadly, as lockdowns continue in some states, we’ve seen politicians from both sides engaging in those kinds of self-serving behaviour.

Still, who needs to worry when we have the Croods to guide our way out of the pandemic.

“It’s like that movie,” Prime Minister Scott Morrison explained to Channel 9 last week, describing his COVID-19 exit plan in a way that raised eyebrows, and not a little mockery, around the world.

“In The Croods, people wanted to stay in the cave … and that young girl, she wanted to go out and live again and deal with the challenges of living in a different world. COVID is a new, different world, and we need to get out there and live in it. We can’t stay in the cave.”

Jane McCredie is a Sydney-based health and science writer.



The statements or opinions expressed in this article reflect the views of the authors and do not represent the official policy of the AMA, the MJA or InSight+ unless so stated.




The Prime Minister's reference to The Croods is an international embarrassment
  • Strongly agree (66%, 37 Votes)
  • Strongly disagree (13%, 7 Votes)
  • Disagree (11%, 6 Votes)
  • Agree (9%, 5 Votes)
  • Neutral (2%, 1 Votes)

Total Voters: 56

Loading ... Loading ...

6 thoughts on “Why worry when the Croods are our role models?

  1. Armando says:

    A new world order in such that humanity have to live with the Covid 19 virus, good for the vaccinated ones and best of luck for the anti-vaxers or the deniers of the reality happening.

    As the Coalition Allies have withdrawn from Afghanistan, they have to accept and live with new Taliban order and likely have also to make dealings and coordinate with the Islamic rulers for the sake of Afghan population peace and safety in years to come.

    We all have to make adjustment or acclimatise with the current condition or we just self-destruct.

  2. Michael King says:

    I can’t help but think that much of this issue is a direct consequence of the claim for rights. My own philosophy is that there are very few rights, in that it is right that I should have something regardless what I do or don’t do. Most of what are touted as rights are actually privileges afforded by the type of society we have decided to create. In this world view, every privilege carries an attendant responsibility. You want clean water? Then you must be prepared to contribute to the infrastructure that provides it. Same with roads, hospitals, education, you name it. Needless to say, there are some who simply cannot, for whatever reason, contribute. As a compassionate society we have decided to create a system that will provide for the needs of those folk. In order to do so, those of us who can contribute have accepted that responsibility. Sadly, when a cry is raised that something is a human right (such as provision of clean needles to injecting drug users in prisons- yes, that was claimed to be a basic human right) folk demand it without thinking about their responsibility or who is going to pay for it, as nothing is truly free.

  3. Maryanne says:

    The PM’s reference to the Croods was I understand directed to the premiers of WA and Qld and their decision that they will keep their borders shut even though the country reaches 70% vaccination rate. As far as I am concerned calling this “crood mentality” is nothing to be embarrassed about. Easy to be a “crood” when your income is not affected by lockdowns and the federal govt gets us into increasing debt to subsidise premiers’ decisions. What about those working for themselves who cannot afford to be croods and the children and youth who are suffering from being isolated and who do not want to be croods?

    It is clear that the only countries trying now for covid elimination are China and New Zealand, the former by using draconian and coercive measures. All other countries have pragmatically accepted that vaccination is only the way out, that we cannot stay in hard lockdowns forever and that people will need to accept increased deaths from covid once lockdown restrictions are eased. Despite harsh lockdown in Victoria, it would appear that the delta strain has now established itself in the community.

    It is easy to criticise politicians for their words and in hindsight for their mistakes, but as doctors we should focus our efforts on helping with the vaccination roll out and persuading our patients to accept Vaxzevria so that we can reach the target set by Doherty institute. We will soon be facing increasing workload treating covid sick antivaxxers so let us work towards limiting their numbers rather than quibble about the se of the word “crood”.

  4. Ben Clark says:

    We all have a different view as to what’s a reasonable ” social contract” .For example, its my view that preventing Australian citizens from returning to their home country is an unacceptable infringement of a basic human right. Others think differently. I suspect nobody reading this would be on the side of your angry “anti-masker”.It is important to acknowledge however, that no matter how egregious the behaviour it serves no one to dismiss his/ her concerns regarding “rights” out of hand.

  5. James Hurley says:

    If only we had a leader who knew the difference between a fire hose and a photo opportunity

  6. Max says:

    Too smug by half.
    And a bit of selective vision: only seeing nutters at the protests because that was all you wanted to see.
    This would be the Hobbes of the Leviathan of course: Big Government in our terms.
    Never leave the running of the country to doctors. Single focus.
    Coincidentally, their incomes have been ticking along nicely all the way through this pandemic.
    All in this together?: I doubt it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *