Spiritual care in palliative care: How narrative medicine can restore meaning, connection and dignity
Spiritual care in palliative care can help patients find meaning, connection and purpose through storytelling, and is increasingly recognised as an essential part of supporting people with life-limiting illness
The Lancet Commissioners’ Report on the Value of Death told us we need to re-balance the care of life-limited people. They say we have over-medicalised this stage of life in the West, treating it as physiological and not also spiritual. The report champions the enactment of the whole biopsychosocial-spiritual model of healthcare. But what does “spiritual” mean in secular Australia? What could it look like in practice? And who is responsible for providing it?
Defining spiritual care in palliative care
Harvard Medical School researchers define “spiritual” as “the way individuals seek and express meaning and purpose, and experience connectedness to self, others, the significant or sacred”. Some may call this “existential” care to distinguish it from religious.
How, and by whom, could the breadth and depth of such care be enacted? One clue is the Commissioners’ reference to “stories”.
Neuroscience and stories
Neuroscientific research affirms the value of stories. It supports the practice of narrative medicine, offering science that underpins sociologist, Arthur Frank’s claim: “reflection on memory makes the self an object of wonder.”
Mindful of the research, we revisited the documented observations of almost 50 experienced volunteers in Eastern Palliative Care’s (EPC) Biography Program. EPC offered the first such program in Australia in 2006. Patients reconstruct their life stories supported by a trained volunteer.
We applied thematic analysis and the close reading, practiced by narrative medicine, to analyse their words.
In the words of the volunteers
The selected observations below represent the many. They are grouped under themes reflecting Harvard’s definition.
Reconnecting with self
Reconstructing earlier, half-forgotten versions of themselves proved transporting for many patients, sometimes, temporarily, transcending their physical frailty. “Some seem to be back in that place or with that person”, noted one volunteer. Another witnessed a patient “totally in that moment” in ways that “took me there with him”.
One day a volunteer “walked into a room when the client was lying down having difficulty breathing and struggling to sit up”, and thought the session can’t happen. But, as talk progressed slowly, the patient became entirely “focused elsewhere, and even smiling”, recreating “the things that have given their lives meaning”. Another bore similar witness to “two clients very near the end of their lives” yet, in telling their stories “transported from their pain to another place”.
Connecting with others
Despite knowing patients “for such a short period of time”, declared one volunteer, “by the end of the biography, it feels like you have known them for years and that they are part of your life”.
Trained to listen actively and non-judgementally, volunteers can help patients feel comfortable, engaged and trusting so they can talk openly in a safe space. “They confide in you about things they wouldn't [normally] say”, said one. While another welcomed “how my client opens up from one visit to the next”.
For some there was a sense of reciprocal caretaking. One volunteer felt the privilege of listening to “people from many different walks of life, cultures and attitudes” and the trust offered through the stories of their inner worlds. Another observed how “hearing about people's lives, their choices, decisions and reflections on their pathways sometimes leads me to think about mine”.
Appreciating how their life stories could contribute to the enrichment of their biographers, in turn added to patients’ sense of purpose and identity.
Seeking and expressing meaning
Reconstructing their stories helps patients become the active agents of their lives again, offering a renewed sense of control. Recalling their past can restore a rich, whole sense of life, its meaning and purpose, much larger than the present limitations imposed by their bodies and different means of communicating with others. For one patient and his family the “biography provided a new focus — it became the source of conversation with friends and family rather than the focus of conversation being on the illness”.
Even the re-telling of difficult times could help resolve unhappy events. One patient “was very angry with her daughter…. [but] by session five…was able to forgive her…. She was able to say, despite everything, she loved her daughter”. A husband and father, who had never felt able to declare his love for his family, could through story “verbalise his thoughts and love for his grown-up children and his love for his wife, and to have this written down for them to read”. His story became an ongoing source of comfort after he died, a continuing presence in absence.
Life storytelling may not suit everyone. But the evidence of these volunteers suggest it is one vehicle for the spiritual care of many with life-limiting illness.
How treating doctors could introduce narrative medicine to patients
Access to biography programs is currently limited to palliative care programs, while the need for spiritual care may occur much earlier in the disease trajectory. They are also little known and constrained by volunteer’ numbers.
If many are challenged spiritually by a life-limiting diagnosis, could the trusted relationship with their doctor be leveraged to introduce the narrative process of the program more widely to interested patients? Could the training and resources of volunteers be repurposed to enable doctors to enable their patients to assume responsibility for their spiritual care?
We have begun a pilot research project with doctors associated with EPC, and Narrative Medicine specialists, also doctors, to find out.
Elizabeth Summerfield has an MA (Research) and a PhD (Science) from the University of Melbourne. She researches and writes on systems thinking in leadership and learning organisations.
Dr Jack C.I. Wang is a Palliative Medicine Specialist who currently works primarily in Eastern Health and Eastern Palliative Care, across inpatient, clinic and community settings. His main interest is in contiunuing medical education, service improvement and exploration of care beyond the physical suffering of those living with a life limiting illness.
Dr. Chien-Che Lin is a Palliative Medicine Specialist Consultant at several hospitals and community palliative care services in Victoria, including Eastern Palliative Care. He also works as a General Practitioner on Saturdays. Committing to support people with progressive, incurable diseases to live as well as possible, he has continuously dedicated clinical and administrative commitments to improve care in community settings. He chairs and/or is a member of several professional advisory and working groups, including the Safer Care Victoria Palliative Care Community of Practice supported by Department of Health Victoria.
The statements or opinions expressed in this article reflect the views of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official policy of the AMA, the MJA or InSight+ unless so stated.
If you would like to submit an article for consideration, send a Word version to mjainsight-editor@ampco.com.au.
Subscribe to the free InSight+ weekly newsletter here. It is available to all readers, not just registered medical practitioners.
You may also like
VIEW MORENewsletters
Subscribe to the InSight+ newsletter
Immediate and free access to the latest articles
No spam, you can unsubscribe anytime you want.
By providing your information, you agree to our Access Terms and our Privacy Policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.