Issue 33 / 31 August 2015

US psychologists recently demonstrated that showing parents the harms caused by vaccine-preventable infectious diseases is more effective than providing scientific information to refute anti-vaccination attitudes.
In fact, the psychologists found that providing scientific information could backfire or be ineffective with vaccine sceptics or those with less favourable attitudes to vaccines. Sceptics tend to discount or ignore evidence contrary to their existing beliefs, and it can lead them to look for more information to support what they already believe.
The evidence for the efficacy of immunisation is indisputable — witness the eradication of smallpox from the world and near eradication of polio, which remains endemic in just three countries: Afghanistan, Nigeria and Pakistan.
There is also plenty of evidence on the control of other vaccine-preventable infectious diseases. Distinguished Australian scientist Dr Brian Feery provided one of the first decade-by-decade summaries of deaths in Australia from common preventable diseases from 1926 to 1995, and related these to the decade in which the relevant vaccine was introduced, which has since been updated. 
Number of deaths from diseases commonly vaccinated against, Australia, 1926 to 2005, by decade
The last outbreak of polio in Australia was in 1961‒1962. This dreaded condition has not been seen in Australia by those born after this date. It is a similar pattern for diphtheria.
The markedly low incidence of other vaccine-preventable infections in Australia such as measles, Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) epiglottitis and meningitis, and congenital rubella, for instance, means young parents have not seen what these conditions can do to vulnerable children. They cannot comprehend the suffering, complications and sometimes death of children who are infected with these diseases.
Add this lack of firsthand experience to the confirmed scepticism of parents with anti-vaccination views about scientific data, and it is easy to see why doctors struggle to convince these parents that vaccination is an essential protection for their children.
If doctors are faced by such scepticism, they could ask whether parents have seen cases of vaccine-preventable infectious diseases such as diphtheria, tetanus or polio, and what they know about the impact of these diseases on children. Would they recognise symptoms of these diseases in their children?
Because vaccines have been so successful in preventing many infectious diseases, the only practical way to show parents these diseases is through audio-visual recordings of actual clinical illnesses.
“Protect your baby for life”, an educational video first produced in the 1990s, is a good starting point. You could show it to sceptical parents and then ask: “Would you really run the risk of your child suffering like this?”
The ball is then truly in their court.
Professor Clem Boughton is Emeritus Professor at the University of NSW and was formerly chairman and senior physician at the Division of Infectious Diseases at Prince Henry Hospital, Sydney.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The public education video titled “Protect your baby for life”, which briefly profiled particular infectious diseases so parents were better informed about immunising their children, was made possible by Professor Boughton and his colleagues from the Department of Infectious Diseases, Prince Henry and Prince of Wales hospitals and the University of NSW. The Sydney School of Medicine, University of Notre Dame Australia, digitised the video so that it can be accessed online. Permissions were granted by the patients and/or their parents featured in the video.


Are parents given enough information about vaccine-preventable diseases when children are due for vaccinations?
  • No – more education is essential (75%, 40 Votes)
  • Maybe – depends on the disease (17%, 9 Votes)
  • Yes (8%, 4 Votes)

Total Voters: 53

Loading ... Loading ...

5 thoughts on “Clem Boughton: Seeing is believing

  1. tom gavranic says:

    Immunisation should be done in a public education setting as a “rite of passage”. Parents (with their children) should be shown movies of children (or adults) suffering from the diseaes we are immunising against. These films  should be made while these diseasses are still around to be filmed!

  2. Susan Shadforth says:

    My young son developed Haemophilus Meningitis as a toddler, just prior to the introduction of the vaccine, which happened about a year or so later. Watching his initial struggles to stay alive, and then subsequent significant challenges managing with an intellectual disability  and epilepsy, which he will endure for the rest of his life, is extremely painful. My grief  at the loss of  his full potential and observation of his day to day struggles in this competitive world are something I would wish on no parent, except perhaps the antivaccination lobbyists.

  3. Catherine Jane Broun says:

    I cannot BELIEVE that “Anonymous 31/8/2015 11.39” really thinks that – he or she is so WRONG. What about all the Smallpox deaths that occurred before INOCULATION (the correct term) came along – to say nothing of the disfigurement. Last Century, WHOLE families of children were WIPED OUT, by DIPHTHERIA. One only has to take a walk around old graveyards, to see it.

    And now we have a Whooping Cough Epidemic- surprise, surprise!


    ENOUGH of tiny babies DYING already – NEGLECT/ATTITUDE is NO EXCUSE!!!!!!!!!!!

  4. Department of Health Victoria Clinicians Health Channel says:

    Do not feed the troll.

  5. K Heywood says:

    Anyone who has nursed a child through measles will be as amazed as I am to hear the way the disease is described today. It was inconvenient, never life-threatening.

    Claims that it was vaccines that have eradicated smallpox or almost polio could not be further from the truth. You only have to look at Frank Fenner’s book, Smallpox and its eradication,  to see that it was not a result of vaccination. The pictures of the damage done by the vaccine rival the worst ones of the disease.  



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *